A generally outspoken contestant, Lindsey is most remembered for being eliminated in the first episode, then returning through the Outcasts Twist and getting third place. She also caused minor injuries during her brief time in the game.
Despite not being the first contestant to be eliminated, Lindsey was voted out in She's One Tough Bitch, and is the first contestant from her season to be eliminated in the official elimination setting. After being eliminated, Lindsey strangles London, most likely due to London being one of the people to vote for her.
When the surprise Outcasts Twist is announced in Knowing Things Is Mainstream, I Like Surprises, Lindsey comes in along with Evil Valentine, London, and Cierra. She is able to win the challenge, ironically being helped by London, according to Evil Valentine, putting her back in the game. This counts as the only challenge win by Lindsey.
In TIME TO BURN BURN BITCHES, Lindsey tells Cara DeGrossi she can "help shed some light" on who voted out Rylan in the previous episode. Lindsey tells Cara that Captain Magma had asked her to vote out Rylan, but that she didn't follow through, unlike Will and Illusionio. However, it is revealed that Lindsey had voted for Rylan, and that Will hadn't. With the help of Lindsey's partly-truthful reveal, Cara is able to successfully eliminate Illusionio. After Illusionio leaves, Cara tells Lindsey that she "knows what [she's] been hiding." It is unknown what this means.
Lindsey defends her case to Jason in Someone Get That Bitch Some Antidepressants. She brings up the point that Cara, who is also defending herself to Jason, has an automatic jury vote, referring to Rylan. After Jason eliminates Will, he chooses to eliminate Lindsey, wanting to take Cara to the end, who he considered more deserving. Before leaving for the second time, Lindsey smashes her plate into Cara's face.
- Lindsey is the first contestant to return to the game after being eliminated.